The law gives the president power to imprison and deport non-citizens without due process during wartime. Trump claims the Venezuelan gang Tren de Aragua, which heād previously designated a terrorist group, is actually āconducting irregular warfareā and working with the Venezuelan government to destabilize the United States through migration. The DOJ attorneys said Monday that some of Saturdayās deportees were removed from the U.S. under other authorities rather than the Alien Enemies Act.
Pressed by Boasberg about whether they couldnāt discuss the details because they were classified ā he offered to turn off courtroom microphones and huddle privately with the attorneys ā the Justice Department lawyers sought to avoid the question.
All I can say is that Iām authorized to say what we said in the public filing and to the extent that thereās anything more, thatās not relevant, because we do believe that we complied with the court order, which is that no flights took off from U.S. territories after the written order,ā one of the Justice Department attorneys said. (Poor audio quality on the courtās phone line made it difficult to differentiate the two DOJ attorneys.)
āThat does not comply with my order,ā Boasberg shot back, adding that his order was ābroader than that. Itās not a question of ātaking offā from U.S. territory, as anyone who reads a transcript of the hearing knows.ā He said the administration would have to provide a specific reason why it wanted to exclude information from court.
Boasberg didnāt issue any rulings, but set a noon Tuesday deadline for the administration to lay out its position in writing, as well as provide various facts the Justice Department lawyers said Monday that they couldnāt.
āI will memorialize this in a written order, since apparently my oral orders donāt seem to carry much weight,ā Boasberg said.
The hearing punctuated the Trump administrationās increasingly aggressive position toward courts, which has raised fears that the administration will begin regularly ignoring court orders.
Gelernt said at one point that āI think weāre getting very closeā to a constitutional crisis.
On Sunday, Salvadoran President Nayib Bukele, a Trump ally, mockingly wrote āOopsie⦠Too late šā in reference to Boasbergās order. Secretary of State Marco Rubio then reposted Bukele, and Elon Musk called for the impeachment of the judge.
Bukele also released a video showing the deportees being manhandled and sent to the notorious prison, known as the Terrorism Confinement Center, or CECOT.
Without due process, thereās no way to know whether the deportees were Venezuelan gang members or simply asylum-seekers or migrants who were not gang members at all, condemned by the Trump administration to be deported to another countryās prison for no discernable reason.
āOur [Immigrant Defenders Law Center] client fled Venezuela last year & came to [the] US to seek asylum,ā Lindsay Toczylowski, the centerās co-founder, president and CEO wrote. āHe has a strong claim. He was detained upon entry because ICE alleged his tattoos are gang related. They are absolutely not.ā